Kenwood Press

Serving the communities of Kenwood, Glen Ellen and Oakmont

email print
Guest Editorial: 04/15/2017

After 144 years, we are now the Bennett Valley Guild

By Bill Finkelstein, treasurer, Bennett Valley Guild

If you’ve driven by our historic hall at 4145 Grange Road, you may have noticed some changes. A key word has changed on our sign on the street. Why is that? It’s because we have a new name.

We are now the Bennett Valley Guild and our historic hall, built in 1873, is now the Bennett Valley Guild Hall. We are the same organization, a California corporation C0234967 registered March 23, 1949, with the same members, the same mission, at the same location, but with a new name. Why did we do this?

In 2009, the conflict started between the National Grange and the California State Grange (now referred to as the California Guild) under President Bob McFarland over a variety of issues starting with who owns a local chapter’s property. The California Guild’s position is that the hall and assets are owned by the local members. The position of the National Grange and the new State Grange under Ed Komski chartered in July, 2014 is that THEY own the halls and assets.

This conflict could not be resolved in a peaceful manner and the National Master, Ed Luttrell, decided to expel the California organization and take it to the courts. This court action has escalated into more lawsuits.

In the interim, the National Grange Master revoked the charter of the California State Grange on April 5, 2013, kicking out our democratically-elected state organization and all its chapters. The National Master decided to form a new corporation and appointed Ed Komski as its President. This new corporation is called “The Grange of the State of California’s Order of Patrons of Husbandry, Chartered” (C3649252 registered Feb. 21, 2014). The community Granges had no say regarding this organization or its leaders.

Then, to compound the confusion, Komski created a second corporation: the “California State Grange” (C3929444 registered July 21, 2016). It’s currently not clear which of Komski’s corporations is which these days. It’s clear that no one would confuse any of his organizations with any of the Guilds.

In the meantime, the courts ruled that the word “Grange” is a trademark and belongs to the National Grange.

Our California State organization could not continue to use its original name, had to change it, and did so, to the “California Guild.” It is the same California corporation (C0210454 registered Oct. 7, 1946) with a different name. The Bennett Valley Guild nonprofit status derives from the California Guild.

The Bennett Valley Chapter is not now, nor have we ever been, a member of either of Komski’s two California State Granges. It has no jurisdiction over us, so any communication from them regarding Bennett Valley is invalid.

The active members of the Bennett Valley Guild decided the best course of action was to change our name to avoid being sued for trademark infringement and to avoid the onerous requirement imposed if we adopted Ed Komski’s new bylaws, which would give him authority to revoke our charter and strip us of our property and other assets.

The lawsuits between the National Grange and Komski’s California Grange and the California Guild are ongoing. So far, the courts are ruling in the favor of the California Guild on all matters of importance except the Trademark case. The court has affirmed in both the Federal and State Courts that the Guild is a bona fide California corporation and its officers and directors are governed and protected by the laws of our state and nation. Further the Federal court has found there is no contractual relationship between any of the Grange entities and any of the Guild chapters.

These findings have dealt a major blow to the land grab orchestrated by the National Grange and Mr. Komski, who are ruthlessly attempting to financially strangle the Guild, its officers and staff.

About the Bennett Valley Guild

The Bennett Valley Guild has been an essential part of Bennett Valley for over 144 years. Most people know that the Bennett Valley Guild Hall is an historical building built in 1873. What people may not know is that this Guild is an active organization that continues to hold monthly meetings working to “Enhance our Environment through Community Action.”

The Bennett Valley Guild has partnered with the Bennett Valley Community Association (BVCA), offering the hall for community events, meetings, and informative speakers. The BVCA also co-sponsors the Guild’s annual Bennett Valley Picnic, which is held the first Sunday in June. This year the 145th Annual Picnic will be held on June 4 from noon to 4 p.m. The picnic raises funds for the upkeep and maintenance of our historic hall. The Guild is also the site of the Bennett Valley Emergency Preparedness emergency shelter, supporting all rural Bennett Valley.

For information, please contact Bill Finkelstein, treasurer and executive committee member at 536-1026 or

Readers may submit articles of approximately 800 words on topics of local interest for the Guest Editor column. Email Although we intend to print all submissions, we do reserve the right to refuse to publish any article.

Recently Published:

02/15/2018 - Stop and pick the blackberries
02/01/2018 - Supervisors should reinstate vacation rental moratorium
12/15/2017 - Home… at last
11/15/2017 - Animal rescuer tells what it was like behind the lines
06/01/2017 - Transit Occupancy Tax revenue can help fix our roads
04/15/2017 - Country road lament
04/15/2017 - After 144 years, we are now the Bennett Valley Guild
03/01/2017 - Oakmont’s fiscal situation – setting the record straight
02/15/2017 - Highway 37 improvements are necessary and costly
02/15/2017 - Restore fiscal responsibility, vote for “We Are All Oakmont”
01/15/2017 - Worth Our Weight (in gold!)
12/01/2016 - Don’t allow commercial or cottage cannabis cultivation in rural residential areas
09/01/2016 - 60 days in Kenwood
04/15/2016 - Spring Fawn? Leave it alone!
04/01/2016 - Does closing developmental centers mean the end of choice in the Department of Developmental Service

Community Calendar

Volunteer training for Jack London and Sugarloaf parks
Santa Rosa Youth Symphony groups return to Oakmont
Oakmont Sunday Symposium
Sonoma Speaker Series features journalist Keller
OVA, Golf Club Town Hall
The right to privacy topic at SIR #53
Hiking for Fitness series starts
Fawn Rescue Benefit Luncheon
Free kids hike to ancient redwood
Sonoma County Trails Council work day
Healthy Parks, Healthy People Hike